Philip Levitt, M.D. - Company Message
My Blog

Who’s Protecting the Patient?

Public access to the National Practitioner Data Bank was blocked by the Department of Health and Human Services during the past month. A doctor listed therein for having been sued successfully by several patients complained that a newspaper in his area had published that he had also been disciplined by one of the hospitals where he practiced. Alan Bavley, a reporter for the Kansas City Star, had done some detective work with encoded information in the data bank, found the hospital disciplinary measure and by publishing it crossed a line drawn by HHS.

The data bank was established in the eighties by Congress to store information about all disciplinary actions against doctors by their hospitals and by the state boards of medicine. An additional portion of the information, and, in practice, by far the largest, comes from malpractice insurance carriers about settlements and verdicts in medical liability cases. It gives a summary of each case which is often based on the complaint submitted by the patient’s lawyer. The doctors’ names were never accessible to the public. Only in the last few years, just over a decade, was the bank’s data available to the public but it was obscured by assigning numbers to the doctors and keeping their names secret.

The reporter’s research, which included partial access to the bank’s data via its public portal, had enabled him to put 2 and 2 together. He already had the doctor’s name and the scenarios of multiple lawsuits against him, things that were in the public domain. He had been assisted by at least one plaintiffs’ attorney. By matching the summaries of the allegations in several suits with those of a doctor listed in the data bank he was able to break the code and match the name to the number. Taking things a fateful step further, he found a hospital disciplinary report under the number. Such a report is not in the public domain and, a spokesman for HHS maintains, was illegal for the Star to publish. An $11,000 fine was threatened but the newspaper went ahead with the report anyway. Then HHS shut down public access fearing that other reporters could easily triangulate the data and get hospital disciplinary reports on other doctors.

I became familiar with using the data bank as a hospital chief of staff for five years. The only people allowed to use it unveiled were officials of the hospitals which had received applications for staff privileges from a doctor. They were required by the law that established the bank to check out all the entries for an applicant, who was, for them only, identified by name. The information was read by the privileged few lay administrators and doctors who had to make recommendations whether or not to accept the new doctor on their staff. It was meant to protect the public from harm by unfit doctors. In practice, very few are kept off hospital staffs this way.

A large minority of American hospitals have never reported a doctor for having been disciplined at their institutions to the data bank. The malpractice insurers, on the other hand, are reliable reporters to both the data bank and the state boards of medicine. One of the chief concerns expressed in the Kansas City Star was that the Kansas state board of medicine had not taken action against the doctor even though several cases which had resulted in judgments against the doctor had been reported to it by the insurers in compliance with state law. Most states have such laws.

In my state, Florida, a large proportion of malpractice settlements or verdicts are reportable to the state. All reports are investigated. The last time I checked with a lawyer who defends doctors, she told me that only about 1% of such reports result in actions against a doctor’s license. There have been revocations based on a plethora of judgments against a single doctor, but usually the malpractice cases do not cross the threshold for action. There are several explanations for this. The legal standard for many state boards of medicine is higher than that for malpractice suits. The latter require that the predominance of the evidence go against a defendant. The former insists that “clear and convincing” evidence be presented.

Many malpractice cases are settled to avoid court costs. Many have questionable merit. A Harvard study showed that 40% of about 1300 closed cases were invalid, most involving no liability. Although most boards of medicine can be very severe and are still the strongest bulwark of the public against bad practitioners, they still are vulnerable to the criticism of leniency toward their peers because almost all boards are made up mostly of doctors.

When the public portal to the data bank was open, a tabulation was made that showed that an average of only 250 of America’s 650,000 doctors had their licenses revoked each year, less than 0.04%.  Some would argue that this is too small a fraction of physicians. Others say that the doctors who get reported to the state are often the victims of flawed health care delivery systems and this must be taken into account in determining what, if any, disciplinary measure is appropriate in the case of an individual practitioner. There is a joint statement of the state medical boards of the U.S. and Canada in 2008 to that effect.

When the Harvard Medical Practice Studies, the gold standard on medical errors, were done, they were blind to the existence of physicians whose actions resulted in multiple adverse events, so that we do not have a good handle on how many doctors there are with repeatedly bad outcomes. This is data that is sorely lacking and must be obtained before we can say that certain practitioners are the source or not of a disproportionate number of adverse events.

That would require a much greater transparency than the medical profession has tolerated up until now. From that standpoint, shutting down the data bank is a step in the wrong direction.

7 Comments to Who’s Protecting the Patient?:

Comments RSS
rolex replica on Monday, May 19, 2014 9:47 PM
Because they are accepted as a healthy track record , nice to accept all human beings , this emblem to plan an acceptable appliance architecture aggregation for assignment , valuable .
Reply to comment

Online custom on Thursday, July 6, 2017 2:19 AM
Your capacity to specific your mind and thoughts more honestly may be very magnificent. Your weblog helped me to get extra suitable writing capabilities. thanks so much for this helpful put up.
Reply to comment

can someone do my essay for me on Monday, August 13, 2018 6:21 AM
Your work is good. I want more information about this topic. Can you provide a good documentation on this topic. For document format you can go through . It is one of the cheapest writing service.
Reply to comment

Tjan Kok Pin on Sunday, January 13, 2019 11:11 PM
dengan cara yang salah, menampakkan diri dan meneganling 7 jual baja h beam jual pipa boiler jual plat abrex 400 jual plat asme516 grade70 jual plat astm a285 c jual plat astm516 70 jual plat boiler jual plat hardox jual plat hb 400 jual plat high strenght jual plat high tensile sm490 yb Pabrik Wiremesh Supplier Besi Unp Baja Harga besi wf Jual sch 40 Jual sch 40 Supplier bondek Supplier besi hollow undangan pernikahan ada foto Pabrik Besi Pipa Baja Schedule 80 Agen Besi Unp Baja Jual besi wf Jual Jaket Parka Jaket Parka Jual Jaket Parka Jaket Parka undangan pernikahan kalender undangan pernikahan bahasa inggris islam undangan pernikahan islami undangan pernikahan unik dan murah undangan pernikahan modern undangan pernikahan online undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan amplop surat undangan pernikahan simple undangan pernikahan murah undangan pernikahan unik undangan pernikahan artis undangan pernikahan modern undangan pernikahan artis undangan pernikahan arab undangan pernikahan undangan pernikahan Jual besi hollow Jual besi hollow Toko besi siku Toko pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 undangan pernikahan bentuk tas Supplier Besi H beam Agen Wiremesh Besi baja Jual plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton master steel ms Supplier besi hollow Supplier besi hollow Toko pipa besi baja sch 40 sch 80 Toko besi hollow undangan pernikahan ada fotonya Supplier Besi Beton Toko Wiremesh Besi baja Supplier plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton ksty Toko besi hollow Toko besi hollow Toko Plat besi Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan aneh Jual Wiremesh Besi baja Toko plat kapal besi baja Pabrik besi beton krakatau steel Agen besi hollow Agen besi hollow Toko besi h beam Toko besi wf baja undangan pernikahan amplop Pabrik Welded Beam T beam King Queen Cross Castellated Beam Harga Wiremesh Besi baja Agen plat kapal besi baja Distributor besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton gunung garuda Harga pipa besi Harga pipa besi Toko besi unp Toko Plat besi plat kapal undangan pernikahan online Pabrik Plat Bordes Kembang Supplier Besi Siku Baja Harga besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton delcoprima Jual pipa besi Jual pipa besi Toko besi cnp Toko besi h beam baja undangan pernikahan anti mainstream Pabrik Plat Besi Hitam Agen Besi Siku Baja Jual besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton cakra steel cs Supplier pipa besi Supplier pipa besi Toko besi hollow Toko besi cnp undangan pernikahan cantik dan murah Pabrik Plat Kapal Bki Krakatau Steel Toko Besi Siku Baja Supplier besi siku baja Pabrik besi beton bjku Toko pipa besi Toko pipa besi Toko besi beton Sni Ulir Polos undangan pernikahan unik Pabrik Jual Besi Siku Baja
Reply to comment

Neck Pain Frankfort on Wednesday, June 12, 2019 3:55 AM
Great tips and very easy to understand. This will definitely be very useful for me when I get a chance to start my blog.
Reply to comment

Women’s Western Leather Jacket on Friday, December 27, 2019 6:31 AM
Thanks for sharing this interesting and amazing post with us, I really like this post.
Reply to comment

Cleveland M. Oliver on Wednesday, May 13, 2020 3:54 AM
There is always a negative side of the internet that the kids may get derailed from their path. Many surveys show that half of the parents do not explain their children to online safety. But not talking and discussing these things will make the situation worse Click Here To Know More.
Reply to comment

Add a Comment

Your Name:
Email Address: (Required)
Make your text bigger, bold, italic and more with HTML tags. We'll show you how.
Post Comment


Recent Posts

Patient Safety Must Be Carefully Rethought
A New Hope for Reducing Medical Errors
Are Our Hospitals Getting Safer?
Lack of Insight
Errors in surgery are individual, not systemic


doctors' offices safety
hospital safety
military physician sacrifices
powered by